Sunday, November 22, 2015

An Expert Reviews Natan's NDE Video

For reference, see the post with the original video (later removed) and part of the video with English subtitles.

See also BIN who references her.


At Sun Nov 22, 11:55:00 AM 2015, Anonymous Anonymous said...

So much for all the naysayers.

Thank You so much!

Do you know when/if the rest of his video will be translated?

Sarah G K

At Sun Nov 22, 12:47:00 PM 2015, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I read an Israeli police interrogator said the same thing..he was telling the truth.

At Sun Nov 22, 03:03:00 PM 2015, Anonymous Anonymous said...

What she actually said is that he appears truthful. In other words, he believed his experience. But Nothing is 100 percent in her line of work. She also stated that the Rabbi's constant questioning impeded Natan's ability to fully tell his story. To me, the Rabbi seemed to direct Natan with his questions instead of waiting until he finished his story And then ASK questions. You could see the kid seemed confused at times and looked to the Rabbi. Perhaps the Rabbi just wanted to keep him on track but he did a poor job of it.--Diaspora Ro

At Sun Nov 22, 10:22:00 PM 2015, Blogger bigben said...

She states clearly that she was paid to do this video. She does not state who paid her. Why indeed would anyone pay her? This does not pass the smell test.

At Mon Nov 23, 12:56:00 AM 2015, Blogger Neshama said...

Anonymous @ 3:03. Yes if one pays attention to her disclaimers, she only says that he believes his experience. You are so right. Once he becomes an adult, with years of learning behind him can he tell us what he really believes happened to him. Like the other 'near death experiences' of adults, he should be able to remember everything with clarity and without a coach sitting next to him.

At Mon Nov 23, 01:57:00 AM 2015, Anonymous Anonymous said...

BigBen, your comment makes no sense. Susan Constantine is a world reknowned expert in this field. Did you think she would spend her time on this matter for free? Do you think she faked her opinion or that someone stole her identity? She attested in the video that she was impartial. This video made a lot of waves. So what if someone paid her? How is that relevant to her opinion in any way? So I guess any time someone is compensated for their expertise 'it does not pass the smell test'. I guess your employer is going to be happy when you show up for work on Monday and don't want to get paid.

At Mon Nov 23, 02:05:00 AM 2015, Blogger אורנה ניצבת. דוד מלך ישראל חי וקיים said...

Exactly a year ago, on the first yahrzeit of Harav Ovadia Yosef, someone else got a similar experience after poisoning by FULL(fava beans). One thing that screamed for my attention was the fact that both where spoken to and comforted by Harav Ovadia Yosef himself on the day of his yahrzeit. The other person who told her experience long before (year ago) was send back by the Tzadik after comforting her that everything will be ok. By this I am certainly positive above big piece of truth in his story, especially because the story of the year before was not brought up to the media.
All we have to do is a real tshuva. Just do it. All the NESHAMOT, draw close to Hashem, by living the Torah as best as you can.
Take care!

At Mon Nov 23, 02:44:00 AM 2015, Blogger Shimshon said...

I was also annoyed by the constant interruptions of his telling of his experience. People just don't know how to listen today, and this rabbi is as guilty as anyone else of that.

About halfway through the subtitled video, Natan was in the middle of explaining about the souls he saw who were neither in Gan Eden or Gehenom, and how they were wandering around, and they were...

And then, just as he was about to explain something that sounded interesting, and that he was emphasizing (and even seemed somewhat important important to him), was (rudely, in my opinion) sidetracked, and the discussion never returned to this other category of soul he saw.


Post a Comment

<< Home